Member Businesses: Dining

Bay View Bakery

A delightful bakery, featuring a wide variety of freshly baked breads, pies, cookies, muffins, sticky buns, scones, croissants, sweet and savory turnovers, cupcakes, gluten-free items plus a delicious assortment of sugar-free chocolates and “sweets”. Coffee, tea and other beverages are available. Patrons may choose to enjoy our treats in one of our three sitting rooms or outdoors on one of our patios. Special orders are encouraged!

  • Facebook

142 Main Street
Blue Hill, ME 04614 United States

Website

(207) 669-5735

The Thurston Company

Restaurant and bar now open in Blue Hill!

Call for reservations (207)374-7166

66 Main St
Blue Hill, ME 04614 

Website

(207)374-7166

Tinder Hearth LLC

Wood-fired European-style bread, pizza and pastry bakers operating year round out of a beautiful farmhouse in Brooksville. Find the bread and pastries at markets around the Peninsula, and don’t miss their popular pizza nights at the bakery.

  • Facebook

1452 Coastal Rd

Brooksville, ME 04617 United States

Website

(207) 326-8381

Sandy’s Blue Hill Cafe

Down Home Cooking for Breakfast, Lunch and Dinner.  House-Roasted Coffee and Full Espresso Bar.  Craft Beers, Ciders and Wines.  Indoor and Outdoor Seating.  All in a Casual Setting in Historic Downtown Blue Hill.

  • Facebook

Sandy's Blue Hill Cafe

40 Main Street
Blue Hill, ME 04614 United States

Website

(207)374-5550

Pugnuts Ice Cream Shop

Pugnuts – A coastal Maine experience – unique flavors and hospitality in our 19th century general store.

We use only premium ingredients in our Gelato and Ice Cream.  Ice cream and flavorings are sourced locally in New England.  Gelatos and Sorbets are made with imported Italian  ingredients as well as naturally produced flavorings and colorings.

We rotate 12 flavors of Ice Cream, 10 flavors of Gelato and 2 Sorbets in our display cases in the Surry shop, and others are available on a daily basis.

Pugnuts offers a wide variety of Ice Cream and Gelato cakes for your special occasion.  We always have a selection in our freezer case at our shop in Surry, and we are happy to make your cake to order with 24 hour’s notice.  We can do virtually any flavor that we offer (excluding sorbets) although for the best effect we suggest you use single or combinations of single flavor ice creams rather than swirls or varigates.

  • Facebook

1276 Surry Road
Surry, ME 04684 United States

12-6pm Closed Mondays

Website

207-412-0086

Perry’s Lobster Shack

Perry’s Lobster Shack is a small family owned and operated second generation seafood restaurant located in Surry Maine! Perry’s was originated in 1998 and has been a highly sought after restaurant ever since!  We offer one of a kind views, service and food. Come enjoy our famous lobster rolls on our outside dock area. We can be reached by land or sea. If you join us for, lunch don’t be surprised if you see some of the Lobster men unloading their catch of the day. If dining on our beautiful pier doesn’t leave you enough time, that’s okay! We offer live or cooked items to go and now accept all major credit cards. Come say hello this summer and make sure you come with an empty stomach!

  • Facebook

1076 Newbury Neck Rd
Surry, ME 04684 United States

Website

(207) 667-1955

44 North Coffee

Woman owned, wholesale and retail coffee roasters.  Roasting and brewing organic and fair trade coffee year round in Deer Isle village.

  • Facebook

7 Main St
Deer Isle, ME 04627 United States

Website

207-348-5208

Pentagoet Inn & Restaurant

Discover an oasis of fine food and lodging in a storied village by the sea. The award winning Pentagoet Inn & Restaurant is a charming Queen Anne Victorian hotel offering gracious hospitality, elegant accommodations, and fine dining.

26 Main St
Castine, ME 04421 

Website

207-326-8616

Blue Hill Inn

Blue Hill Inn offers accommodations year round. Located in the heart of the Blue Hill Historic District, the inn is an ideal stop on your coastal Maine vacation. Walk to the many unique shops, galleries and an assortment of dining options. The inn offers eleven elegantly appointed guest rooms with period furniture and antiques and two slightly more modern suites in our Cape House next door. All of our rooms have their own private bath and your stay during the summer season includes a delicious three-course breakfast in our bright and cheerful dining room. In addition, complimentary hors d’oeuvres are served each evening in our fireside parlor or in the apple orchard and gardens from 6-7 p.m. with wines, beers and cocktails available.

  • Facebook

40 Union Street
Blue Hill, ME 04614 

Website

(207)374-2844

Nervous Nellie’s Jams & Jellies

Jam/chutney production; sculpture studio; art park/museum; gift shop of mostly Maine products including exclusive commissioned products found Nowhere Else; & charming tea room

  • Facebook

598 Sunshine Road
Deer Isle, ME 04627 

Website

(207)348-6182

Blue Hill Co-op Community Market & Cafe

4 Ellsworth Road
Blue Hill, ME 04614 

Website

207-374-2165

44 North Coffee

Woman owned, wholesale and retail coffee roasters.  Cafe brewing organic and fair trade coffee year seasonally in downtown Stonington.

  • Facebook

70 Main Street
Deer Isle, ME 04627 

Website

207-348-3043